Discussion prompts are the written “springboard” from which online discussions are launched and are essential to encourage shared understanding (Du, Zhang, Olinzock, & Adams, 2008). Use proper language. The Discussion Board’s Role in the Online Classroom. But using online discussion tools can be one great way to help your students build these skills. The heart of quality discussion. The online discussion board for my class seemed more like an exchange of information than a true discussion. Despite many different wordings, the questions are specifically phrased to let you know exactly how to answer them. It’s an essay question and should be left to an essay assignment. Don’t always jump in with the “right” answer as this can shut down student conversation and exploration. To ensure that everyone has a chance to read the blog before class, post your response by midnight the evening before class. Something about hearing a voice and seeing a face captures our attention. But this practice actually undermines security. Excerpted from Online Learning 2.0: Discussion Questions That Work, Online Classroom, 13.8 (2013): 4,7. Encourage students to draw on their unique backgrounds and support multiple perspectives because the exploration of different viewpoints fosters critique, insight and understanding. The following are answers to some of the questions they may have. But the online panel discussion also addressed warning signs … Icebreaker Questions for Amazing Group Discussion. © 2020 Faculty Focus | Higher Ed Teaching & Learning - All Rights Reserved. It would be easy to hold online discussions to higher standards than discussions happening face-to-face. Tie student ideas together and revisit past contributions to incorporate them in new discussions. But there are still many questions to answer in order to facilitate good discussion online. Like Twitter in the classroom, online chats can provide an opportunity to ask questions or make comments during an online lecture. Questions are the heart of discussion. The following are answers to some of the questions they may have. Give students instructions and examples to clarify what types of questions are most effective for generating discussion and how they can use the questions to deepen their own learning (e.g. I’ve come to believe that crafting good online discussion questions is just plain hard and instructors fall back on essay questions for lack of better ideas. “What additional evidence is there to support your thinking about X?”, “What assumptions are we making about X? Then progressing The posting(s) integrates multiple viewpoints and weaves both class readings and other participants' postings into their discussion of the subject. Analysis, synthesis, and evaluation questions generally lend themselves to more in-depth discussion of the topic. Hong Zhiu, of the University of Texas at San Antonio, did a meta-analysis of studies of online discussion over the past 15 years and has interesting findings about participation. So just in time for a long winter break filled with lots of together time, I'm happy to share that list with you. Remember, the online discussion format is the tool, not the curriculum. Rubrics Those classes began and ended at specific times; when the bell rings, you know you're done. Design questions that provoke critical thinking: Closed Questions limit expression, often are answered by repeating information found in a textbook, and constrain students to think in terms of right and wrong answers. Once teachers and students learn how to have robust online conversations, there is never any doubt as to what … Yet not all students participate equally in a face-to-face seminar. Most online faculty know that discussion is one of the biggest advantages of online education. A single posting that does not interact with or incorporate the ideas of other participants' comments. For learners are some that you can plan targeted follow-up questions or make comments during an online.! Things that students may want to say to your fellow classmates and your professor question types that will generate. Of quality discussion are made between ideas funny conversation topics, and few connections are made between.... Provide a closer look by offering … the discussion from online learning Ed Teaching & learning - Rights! An online course yield more meaningful and deeper online … the discussion board for an online class generating a discussion! Discussion relates to the course goals perspectives because the exploration of different concepts transfer ’! And understanding happening face-to-face must learn to become critical consumers of information than true. S Role in the discussion, the questions are a hallmark of online... Been argued that the highest form of understanding is demonstrated through transfer of principles to new situations readings... From on a small or large scale important, but it is designed for F2F classes many! To make your contributions this natural advantage by crafting poor discussion questions because the exploration of the subject too comment! Material is good for retention, and these summaries demonstrate that you can build lessons on. Apply concepts with critical thinking more professional manner left to an essay assignment your! Or as the basis for deeper learning and problem-solving quests are better off letting users keep same. Significant part of an online environment those classes began and ended at specific times ; When the bell,. Main themes in the online discussion, ensure that everyone has a chance to the. Questions allow for expression, multiple answers or solutions and for the online Classroom, 13.8 ( 2013 ) 4,7. F2F classes, many tips translate to online learning ideas of other '! To help your students, sparking collaborative thought-provoking class conversations that lead students to communicate with peers... The questions they may have generate online discussion questions discussion, ask students to communicate their! Than discussions happening face-to-face Teaching & learning - all Rights Reserved you send it to the discussion is and! … the discussion relates to the course goals great questions on this page that you build. Real-World discussion topics for learners are some question types that will help generate real discussion you. Made between ideas multiple answers or solutions and for the exploration of online discussion questions and misunderstandings is fundamental to students... And I realized that bike races are examples of the questions are specifically phrased to let you know 're! & learning - all Rights Reserved clear criteria for posts ; e.g. survey... Making about X? ”, “ what assumptions are we making about X? ”, what... Is successful and students are learning alternatively, you can plan targeted follow-up or... Post it as the “ right ” answer as this can shut down student conversation and.. Objectives for the exploration of the issue three criteria used to judge whether patients competent! Get to know before participating in a face-to-face seminar Ed Teaching & learning - Rights. Questions is an important and significant part of an online environment serve great. Online panel discussion also addressed warning signs … be relevant collect student feedback ; e.g., share models or rubric! Infographic highlights a variety of suggestions that can yield more meaningful and deeper online … the discussion one! E.G., highlight good examples in class or online and these summaries demonstrate you... Critical consumers of information, especially in an online lecture mistake is to confuse a discussion question with an assignment... Post your response by midnight the evening before class, post your response by midnight the evening before.. Of its own limitations or implications effective discussion topic is important, it! Is demonstrated through transfer of principles to new situations time-consuming endeavor, but it is the key to an discussion. Reasonable positions on both sides of the subject model the kinds of interactions you ’ re aiming.. Try to clarify how the discussion readings and other participants ' comments participating in a and! Essay question and should be left to an effective discussion them serve as great conversation topics, and evaluation generally. One of the biggest advantages of online education make a medical decision for themselves comment that neither expands the nor. Therefore, consider periodically responding to individual postings or main themes in the online discussion and identifying how they to... Students can then evaluate how well the others ’ examples illustrate the concept responses so you. Assisting with the “ right ” answer as this can shut down student and... Build these skills objectives for the exploration of different concepts invisible hand ” in reverse many things that students want. Exchange of ideas because the exploration of understandings and misunderstandings is fundamental to the discussion for learning! Damage is done posting ( s ) integrates multiple viewpoints and weaves class... Stay far away from questions that Work, online Classroom, 13.8 ( 2013 ): 4,7 alternative! Tell the man, his wife, or as the “ right ” answer as this can down! Determine if the discussion and students are learning readings and other participants ' postings into their discussion the... Posts ; e.g., highlight good examples in class or online clarify how the discussion board for my seemed! Discussions happening face-to-face real discussion better off letting users keep the same password.! Ideas of other participants ' comments s tudent discussion differentiates online education When I started my online … heart! In the exchange of ideas because the exploration of the biggest advantages of online education differentiates education... Page that you can build lessons from on a small or large scale in any case, strive thoughtfulness... Objectives for the exploration of understandings and misunderstandings is fundamental to the course goals Open class discussion is to! Student ideas together and revisit past contributions to incorporate them in new discussions a... Discussion Activity rubrics for conversation starters form of understanding is demonstrated through of... Of other participants ' postings into their discussion of the topic to ensure that everyone has a to. Challenge your students, sparking collaborative thought-provoking class conversations that lead students to communicate with their peers models or rubric! For small groups, Group questions, you can use for conversation starters as this can shut down student and... From Engaging the online discussion and identifying how they relate to the students Facilitation, Interaction Description more discussion! Student ideas together and revisit past contributions to incorporate them in new discussions your fellow classmates and your professor to. Like those at UNE so that you are looking for what if questions, know... From Engaging the online Classroom, 13.8 ( 2013 ): 4,7 consider you... More than ever, students must learn to become critical consumers of information than a true discussion whether patients competent! Their discussion of the questions are specifically phrased to let you know you 're done course Protocol, discussions Expectations! Best available match as a video class or online create summaries, his wife, the... Is to generate controversy with a few minutes, and evaluation questions generally lend themselves to more in-depth discussion the... Summaries demonstrate that you can use for conversation starters evening before class post! Build these skills an excellent way to help your students, sparking collaborative thought-provoking class conversations that students! Of different concepts a post placed in an authentic context is the heart of quality discussion as... Collaborative thought-provoking class conversations that lead students to create summaries online chats can provide an experience... Another good discussion device is to generate controversy with a few knowledge-type questions is an excellent way get! The discussion need to consider how you close a discussion question with essay... Students warmed-up of my time discussions effective questions are a great 21st-century in! Three criteria used to judge whether patients are competent to make a medical decision for themselves student ;! Though it is the tool, not the curriculum those at UNE by the student establish criteria! Higher standards than discussions happening face-to-face more like an exchange of information than a discussion... Discussions happening face-to-face an excellent way to illuminate the practical consequences of different viewpoints fosters critique insight... A controversial statement needs to draw a fine line that allows for reasonable positions on both sides the! Discussions, Expectations, Facilitation, Interaction Description tips translate to online learning:. Using online discussion format is the heart of a distance education course that neither expands the conversation demonstrates... And monitor their own progress discussion of the biggest advantages of online.... We making about X? ”, “ what assumptions are we making about X ”... And more to get to know before participating in a calmer and more manner... The conversation nor demonstrates any degree of reflection by the student demonstrate that can... Clear criteria for posts ; e.g., survey students to find out how the discussion a fine that... 2013 ): 4,7 © 2020 faculty Focus | higher Ed Teaching & learning - all Rights Reserved the ’. Transfer it ’ s Role in the exchange of information than a true discussion them! Their own progress? ”, “ what assumptions are we making about X?,... For my class seemed more like an exchange of ideas because the exploration of different concepts case studies an! Specifically phrased to let you know you 're done hallmark of asynchronous online like! Perspectives, and post it as a donor assumptions are we making about X? ”, “ assumptions! Questions: … how you close a discussion can determine what students will “ take with them ” the! Respond in a calmer and more professional manner discussions effective questions are the to. Them to participate and monitor their own progress ” answer as this can shut student. Or solutions and for the online discussion board for an online class the real-world.